Philly Cookie Company

Shortbreads vs Cookies

Picture of Loc Pham
Loc Pham

Owner & Founder of The Philly Cookie Company

Shortbreads vs Cookies: A Similar Origin Story

Cookies and shortbreads share a common origin story, having arisen as convenient, energy-rich bites made for life on-the-go.

Despite their shared roots, these sweet treats veer off in vastly different directions when it comes to preparation, texture, flavor, and history. From the diverse and rich history of cookies to the simple and buttery roots of shortbread, each baked good holds its own unique cultural influences and tales to tell.

Join us as we delve into the fascinating histories of cookies and shortbread.



Shortbread: A Crumbly Treat with a Rich History

What is Shortbread?

Shortbread is an enriched version of biscuits that originated from the British Isles. This classic treat first made its appearance in written records in the 19th century and the term “short” in shortbread refers to its friable, easily crumbled texture.


The Science Behind Shortbread's Texture

The science behind the distinct texture of shortbread lies in its preparation method. By combining fats such as butter or lard with flour before liquids, the fat molecules encase the flour granules, disrupting the formation of gluten. This is due to the transfer of hydrogen from the fats to the flour, occupying the space that would normally be filled by hydrogen from water in the formation of gluten bonds.


In contrast, enriched doughs like brioche or pain au lait require a strong gluten structure to be formed before fats are added. These types of doughs are the polar opposite of shortbread, where gluten development is not a priority.


So, the next time you savor a piece of shortbread, remember that its unique texture is the result of a delicate interplay between science and tradition.

The History and Science Behind America's Favorite Sweet Treat: Cookies

The Dutch Origins of Cookies

Contrary to popular belief, cookies are actually more similar to cakes than biscuits. This sweet treat gets its name from the Dutch word “koek,” which translates to “cake” in English. In many parts of Europe, the term “cookie” is used to describe a small, soft leaven cake.

The Evolution of the American Cookie

The cookie made its debut in America in the 1600s, brought over by Dutch immigrants. After the Revolutionary War, America sought to disassociate itself from Britain, leading to the widespread adoption of the term “cookie” over “biscuit.”


The Science of Leavening in Cookies

One of the key differences between cookies and shortbreads is the use of a leavening agent. Unlike shortbreads, all cookies require a leavening agent to achieve their light and airy texture. This crucial ingredient works by producing carbon dioxide, which expands the cookie dough and creates the desired texture.

So, the next time you enjoy a freshly baked cookie, take a moment to appreciate its rich history and the science behind this beloved sweet treat.

Sweet Treats: A Comparative Conclusion

Shortbreads and cookies share a common origin as convenient energy sources but differ in preparation, texture, taste, and history. Shortbreads are crumbly due to fats before liquids inhibiting gluten development, while cookies are leavened for a light and airy texture. Both treats offer something for everyone, making them popular choices for satisfying sweet cravings.

On Topic

Related Posts

shortbread vs cookie

Shortbreads vs Cookies

Cookies and shortbreads share a common origin story but these sweet treats veer off in vastly different directions when it comes to texture, flavor, and history.

Read More »